Stardew Valley vs Super Mario Odyssey
The comparison
Stardew Valley and Super Mario Odyssey are measured by different sources, so there is no single winner. Each is shown in its own units. Reviewers most praise Stardew Valley for highly addictive gameplay, and Super Mario Odyssey for series-best quality.
As of Jun 23, 2026, Stardew Valley is rated 98% positive on Steam (1,015,132 reviews), and 89/100 on Metacritic (32 critic reviews); Super Mario Odyssey is rated 97/100 on OpenCritic (158 critic reviews), and 97/100 on Metacritic (124 critic reviews). No source is blended; each stands on its own.
Stardew Valley
98% positiveSteam
1,015,132reviews
89/100Metacritic
32critic reviews
Praise
- highly addictive gameplay (13)
- deep, varied content (10)
- cozy, relaxing atmosphere (8)
- strong modding community (3)
Complaints
- difficult fishing minigame (2)
- completionist route demanding (2)
- slow early game (1)
Super Mario Odyssey
97/100OpenCritic
158critic reviews
97/100Metacritic
124critic reviews
Praise
- series-best quality (6)
- innovation and originality (6)
- abundant content and secrets (4)
- nostalgic yet fresh feel (4)
Complaints
- not most challenging entry (1)