As Above, So Below vs The Taking of Deborah Logan
The comparison
On TMDB, As Above, So Below has 6.8/10 and The Taking of Deborah Logan has 6.6/10. As Above, So Below has the higher displayed score on this source. Each source stands on its own; these scores do not establish an overall winner. Reviewers most praise As Above, So Below for original creative concept, and The Taking of Deborah Logan for intriguing premise.
As Above, So Below: 6.8/10 on TMDB (3,943 votes) (snapshot Aug 18, 2026). The Taking of Deborah Logan: 6.6/10 on TMDB (1,522 votes) (snapshot Aug 18, 2026). The snapshots may have been collected on different dates.
As Above, So Below
Snapshot Aug 18, 2026
6.8/10TMDB
3,943votes
Praise
- original creative concept (3)
- atmospheric tension and dread (3)
- claustrophobic setting (2)
- attention to detail (2)
Complaints
- found-footage fatigue (1)
- shaky camera angles (1)
The Taking of Deborah Logan
Snapshot Aug 18, 2026
6.6/10TMDB
1,522votes
Praise
- intriguing premise (2)
- effective buildup (1)
- compelling visuals (1)
Complaints
- inconsistent storytelling (1)
- poor character writing (1)
- found-footage format unnecessary (1)
- late-stage narrative shifts (1)