Red Dead Redemption 2 vs Super Mario Odyssey
The comparison
On Metacritic, Red Dead Redemption 2 has 97/100 and Super Mario Odyssey has 97/100. The displayed scores are tied. Each source stands on its own; these scores do not establish an overall winner. Reviewers most praise Red Dead Redemption 2 for story and characters, and Super Mario Odyssey for nostalgic return to form.
Red Dead Redemption 2: 92% positive on Steam (906,624 reviews), and 97/100 on Metacritic (109 critic reviews) (snapshot Aug 11, 2026). Super Mario Odyssey: 97/100 on OpenCritic (159 critic reviews), and 97/100 on Metacritic (124 critic reviews) (snapshot Oct 19, 2026). The snapshots may have been collected on different dates.
Red Dead Redemption 2
Snapshot Aug 11, 2026
92% positiveSteam
906,624reviews
97/100Metacritic
109critic reviews
Praise
- story and characters (6)
- open world design (6)
- visual quality (4)
- immersive gameplay (4)
Complaints
- social club account issues (3)
- online multiplayer hackers (2)
- slow pacing and tedium (2)
- horse mechanics inconsistency (2)
Super Mario Odyssey
Snapshot Oct 19, 2026
97/100OpenCritic
159critic reviews
97/100Metacritic
124critic reviews
Praise
- nostalgic return to form (6)
- fun and joyful experience (6)
- innovative game mechanics (5)
- rewarding exploration (4)