The Poughkeepsie Tapes vs The Taking of Deborah Logan
The comparison
On TMDB, The Poughkeepsie Tapes has 6.5/10 and The Taking of Deborah Logan has 6.6/10. The Taking of Deborah Logan has the higher displayed score on this source. Each source stands on its own; these scores do not establish an overall winner.
The Poughkeepsie Tapes: 6.5/10 on TMDB (794 votes) (snapshot Aug 18, 2026). The Taking of Deborah Logan: 6.6/10 on TMDB (1,522 votes) (snapshot Aug 18, 2026). The snapshots may have been collected on different dates.
The Poughkeepsie Tapes
Snapshot Aug 18, 2026
6.5/10TMDB
794votes
The Taking of Deborah Logan
Snapshot Aug 18, 2026
6.6/10TMDB
1,522votes
Praise
- intriguing premise (2)
- effective buildup (1)
- compelling visuals (1)
Complaints
- inconsistent storytelling (1)
- poor character writing (1)
- found-footage format unnecessary (1)
- late-stage narrative shifts (1)